On the manner of death...

Both of my parents died violent deaths, one somewhat worse than the other. Both of my wife's parents and also her stepmother died gentle deaths. Holding these two sets of dyings, one in each hand, I find myself weighing them, and wondering.
I think my mother, in the most prescient way possible, was horrified at the prospect of dying on a respirator. She coached those around her about her wishes and left each of us with copies of her living will and advance directives. When we cleaned out her house after her death we found stashed in various places the literature of independent death, more copies of living wills, and more advance directives, both formal and informal. It clearly weighed on her mind. And yet, agonizing on the respirator was how she spent the last week of her life.
My dad didn't worry overmuch about dying. He just didn't want to. He also had a set of living wills and advance directives, but I think he felt ambivalent about them - on the one hand, he didn't want to linger if that was the prospect, but on the other, he very decidedly wanted to keep living. In the end, he had a lot of pain, a lot of hospital, and a failing body; but after the experience with my mom, I was ready to say 'no' to the respirator and did so. Still, he died a hospital death with only me and the palliative care nurse present, with barely the wires and tubes taken away, the night before spent in an exhaustive struggle with a runaway heart and a death sentence of pneumonia.
My mother in law died after a long lingering bout with breast cancer. The day she died was filled with portent - it was Good Friday and the moon the night before was full. She died at home, in her bedroom, with her children and husband surrounding her and son Charles playing hymns softly on the guitar. In the end, she transitioned softly.
My father in law died when his time ran out, at 91, at the end of a process brought about by pulmonary hypertension and heart failure. The year before had been spent with much focus on his greatly swollen left leg, a nasty symptom of what was happening internally but a terrific distracter for us against what was really happening to him. His ending took place in a hospice, surrounded by his children, son Charles playing hymns softly on the guitar. We had copies of the Methodist hymnal but none of us had thought to bring a Bible - so I hunted through the hymnal and eventually found a passage of sorts, a kind of amalgam of different Bible verses that seemed to fit. So, I read it to him at the foot of his bed; shortly thereafter he left quietly.
Even my wife's stepmother, her father's 2nd wife, had a fatal stroke at home, sitting on her couch, surrounded by her beloved cats. She finished at the hospital, but really, her death happened at home in a way that I think she would have preferred.

